If you are a Chem PhD student enrolled in 2302894 you will be assessed as part of your course. The following rubric is used for the assessment of the 3MT Presentation
For GCS students. Your presentation is judged separately as part of your Thesis/Dissertation course using this same rubric
| Attribute | “D” Does Not Meet Expectations | “M” Meets Expectations | “E” Exceeds Expectations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall quality of presentation | Fail “M” | The presentation must have at least 5 of the following qualities: – Easy to see/read – Good sequence – Correct citations – Well prepared – Easy to hear (loud voice) – Non-monotonic – Good usage of language | “M” and one of the followings: – Show excellent presentation skill – Show good command of English during presentation |
| Quality of response to questions | Fail “M” | – Give constructive arguments and/or sound responses – Demonstrate adequate knowledge in their subject area | “M” and all of the followings: – Arguments are well organized – Responses are complete and given in a timely manner – Answers are non-trivia and well-theorized |
| Overall quality of science | Fail “M” | – Work shows certain degrees of creativity and originality – Experiment is well designed | – Work is creative and novel – Work exhibits mastery of subject |
Criteria for Overall Assessment
- Very good: have 3 “Exceeds Expectations”
- Good: have 2 “Exceeds Expectations”
- Pass: have no more than 2 “Does Not Meet Expectations”
- Fail: have 3 “Does Not Meet Expectations”